Total Operating Costs – Batteries Included

Dean Sigler Batteries, Electric Aircraft Components, Electric Powerplants, Sustainable Aviation 1 Comment

Gilles Rosenberger, co-founder of Faraday Aerospace with Michael Friend, former Technology Director for Boeing, commented on a recent entry on H55’s Energic two-seat trainer.  He expanded on the idea of total operating costs for electric aircraft, including the battery replacement.

He congratulated the H55 team and added a point about which your editor will attempt greater diligence.  “But why keeping talking about operating cost and not total cost of ownership?  No pilot, no student is going to pay only few dollars per hours based on the energy cost.  Who do you believe is going to pay for other cost including the battery amortization?”

Comparative battery prices over the last decade. Note the suddend drop for GM batteries because of shift to pouch nickle metal cobalt composition. Note also Tesla’s ability to remain less expensive than Chinese BYD cells

Practicing the best public relations and salesmanship gambits, most aircraft sales operations don’t mention the eventual cost of battery replacement.  Gilles, who can speak from experience because of his work on the Airbus E-Fan project, says, “Best industry standards seem to be today 1.000 € (or $1,125) per kWh for a 1,000 cycles non-certified battery pack.”

What Do Replacement Batteries Cost, Anyway?

Checking this against both automotive and small aircraft numbers, and assuming that aircraft certification will invariably raise prices, we present a few real-price examples.

A Nissan Leaf battery pack – a bit pricey, depending on its life time

Nissan Leafs have a smaller-than-Tesla pack, with 24 kilowatt-hour capacity for earlier models and 40 kWh for newer cars.  BatteryMan.com says new prices for the 24 kWh units now run $6,200 and $7,800 for the 40 kWh units. At $258 and $195 per kWh respectively, these prices undercut Gilles’s numbers considerably.  Unfortunately, they only apply to Japanese customers with a core battery for exchange.

Motley Fools, in 2016, said Chevy’s Bolt battery cells would cost $145 per kWh at the cell level, with an estimated $210 per kWh at the pack level.  This was better than the Fool’s estimate of $260 per kWh for Tesla’s pack price, although Tesla claimed $190 packs – a controversial number.

Comparing Auto and Airplane Prices

Pipistrel’s January prices for its battery packs, as used on their Taurus electric self-launching sailplane, are 10,200 euros ($11,480) for the 30 kWh unit and 13,600 euros ($15,310) for the 40 kWh size.  This works out to $382.70 and $382.75 per kWh, respectively.  One wonders why the smaller pack works out to be five cents per kWh cheaper.

Pipistrel’s so-called “plug-and-play” electric propulsion system. Batteries are largest, heaviest and most expensive part of setup

Gilles points out, “With the assumption of 400 flight hours per year, the battery life should be in the 3 years range (not every flight will fully discharge the battery), and 50 kWh battery amortization will [require] about 46 €/$51.79 more per hour (50 kWh x 1.000 €/$1.13 per kWh / 400 hrs x 3 years).”  He adds, “Of course these figures will be discussed but nobody can say it will be nothing.”

Regardless of whether Gilles’ higher number or the examples shown above prevail, there is a “balloon payment” that lurks at the end of the battery pack’s life.  Your editor watches automobile auctions on TV occasionally, and notes the sometimes extraordinarily low price a gleaming classic fetches.  Announcers explain that the BMW or Bentley that rolled off the block is hampered by the fact that buyers know the previous owner got the initial mileage out of the vehicle, while second and third owners will face replacement parts bills and high-priced maintenance.  What will these similar considerations mean for the secondary electric aircraft market?

We will endeavor, in this blog, to come up with an average battery replacement cost where a more exact number is not available, to help determine a total operating cost for each aircraft we write about.

1934 patent drawing shows details of Dzuz fastener, or “Dzuz Key” named for its inventor. These held cowling doors and inspection flaps in place.  Whether by design or happy accident, a dime could turn the screw, so instructors would advice their students to always being one flying. Note the small pieces comprising the fastener and its nut-plate mount. Vibration cracks these and requires expensive labor to replace.

We might consider several other miscellaneous factors, such as lower vibration levels for electric craft, in formulating total operating costs.  Those who’ve flown in small, four-cylinder trainers know that cowlings and fairings often show wear and tear on fasteners, brackets, nut plates and other light-weight components.  Electric craft should have lower miscellaneous maintenance costs in this area.

Overall, electric aircraft should have lower total operating costs.  The simplicity and promised longevity of electric motors and controllers compared to the 1,000- to 2,000-hour time between overhaul periods for certified fuel-burning engines should bring about substantially lower numbers for future flight.

Thanks to Gilles Rosenberger for this consideration.

Comments 1

  1. Hello dear friends!
    As pilot of electric airplane I would like to react because there are few misunderstandings in the article.

    First comment – battery prices (info from Pipistrel pricelist).
    Price of replacement battery for electric Taurus is 13 600 EUR (15 310 USD) for 9,7 kWh battery capacity (40Ah) = 15 310 USD / 9,7 kWh = 1 578,35 USD/kWh. 21 kWh replacement battery set for ALPHA Electro costs 26 000 EUR = 29 269 USD / 21 kWh = 1 393,76 USD/kWh.

    Second comment – amortization.
    “Cycle” is not the same like “flight hour”. Example from my flying. 35 kWh battery we use in electric Phoenix give me far over 2 hours of flying (two pilots, MTOM 600 kg). So we can calculate 2-2,5 hours / cycle. Also… at the end of 1 000- 1 200 cycles you still have battery with some capacity. If you take care of the battery (no overheating, precise balancing etc.) than you can still have 80-90% capacity available.
    So I totally agree with:
    “Of course these figures will be discussed but nobody can say it will be nothing.”
    I am glad that thanks to Gilles Rosenberger this topic is discussed and will be very useful to share experience.

    Best regards!
    Martin Stepanek
    Phoenix Air CEO and test pilot

    (Editor’s Note: We welcome Martin Stepanek’s comments. Electric aircraft will prove to be less expensive to operate over time – especially as battery prices come down and longevity increases. Uber and all those big-name aircraft companies would not be investing such huge amounts of money otherwise.)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.